Dinner was eventually a significantly above average meal at twenty-four hour café housed by the hotel where Maddy was staying. And the hour they spent was pleasant, even fun – thanks to the fact that it was all four of them at the table, discussing the happenings of the week, laughing at some of the madness they had found themselves in. Arnav, true to his position as the senior most on the team stayed quiet for the most part and allowed the rest of them to talk, without contradicting anything that was said. Khushi didn’t fail notice or wonder how much of what was intentional and perhaps being used as learning about his people.

At the end of dinner, Khushi and Arnav made their way to the car for the short ride back to the Inn where they were staying. Once seated, awkwardness that had largely been non-existent for the better part of the week, came rushing back, almost as if the night had seeped between them from the memory of another time when there was no distance and yet no heartbreak. Arnav remained quiet as he pulled out of the parking and veered the silent vehicle out to the main road.

“Would you prefer to stay here instead of the Inn?” He asked a couple of minutes of silence later, once again surprising Khushi with how perceptive he really was. She might as well have spelled out the comparison between the more modest dwelling they inhabited versus the clearly more flashy version the rest of their team did.

“The Inn is better suited for long term stay. I know it’s not very luxurious but its fully equipped kitchenette allows you to cook yourself simple meals at least once in a while.”

She shook her head. “I cannot cook to save my life. But I understand.” She really did have moments where she had wondered at what point the constant eating out would get to her – not to mention completely derail her fitness program. Already the week that had gone by had done so without exercise. Eight weeks of this and she would be right back where she started a few months ago. And what would Raagini say? Sighing inaudibly, she looked to her left and found herself asking unexpectedly. “Do you cook?”

“Sometimes.”

She looked out again as the twinkling lights in the clear sky above shimmered even as the silence settled back between them.

“What do you plan to do for the weekend?”

Khushi looked at him in surprise as she realized that she was solely incharge for her time over the weekend in a land where she knew no one and had no place to go to except if she decided to fly out to New York to meet her friend from school. Ha! If only she was the person who could pull off impromptu plans. Inertia and miserliness were bosom buddies and far too deeply entrenched drinking chai from the same pyali in her lazy, middle-class soul. “Sleep.” She answered eventually.

“I will be out till Sunday evening starting tomorrow afternoon but I can take you out for breakfast tomorrow morning.” He said as the car drove in to the parking lot of the Inn and came to a quiet halt just outside her block. “If you’d like, that is.”

He was going to be out all weekend?

Of course he was going to be out all weekend.

He lived here for the most part of a year. He probably had friends to meet. Someone who was more than a friend perhaps? Her heart squeezed at the thought for a microsecond before she mentally smacked herself. She didn’t care. She couldn’t care. This was not AV-Sir. This was not even Arnav. This was AV – Senior Manager, Strategy; Project Lead for Wyatt Motors’s Emerging Markets Entry Strategy assignment being delivered by A&M Consulting at their world headquarters. She knew nothing of this man except that he was a professional superstar. And that was enough.

“No, I’ll be fine. I’ll probably just sleep in till late.”

He finally turned to look at her. She thanked the heavens that it was too dark outside and within for either of them to really see each other. She blinked as she caught the light in his glasses.

“I’ll…Wait a second, I’ll park the car here and hand you the keys. I won’t be needing it and you can…”

‘No, no…I won’t need it. I am hardly the type to sight-see alone. I’ll be fine.”

“Not much to sight-see in Detroit, alone or otherwise. But you will need to eat at least four meals over the next couple of days. And I am sure you have laundry to do.” He said as he revved up the engine and deftly manuevred the vehicle into the empty slot just outside her room. When he turned the ignition off, she let herself out and shivered slightly as the icy air brushed against her face and sneaked into the gaps in her coat. She pulled her arms around her and waited as Arnav walked over and held the keys out.

It was probably just her imagination that she had seen something flicker in his eyes – or perhaps it was the quick reflection of lights from the room above hers in his glasses.

“Good night.” He said softly as her hands closed around the keys and his fell away without contact with her skin.

“Good night.” She whispered with a half smile which he didn’t return.

————

Some time later that night or early next morning as one chose to see it, before closing her eyes in defeat after a lost battle with sleep, she would wonder if there was any way by which she would have forgotten all about that link that Arjun sent her way before he disappeared like he always did. Idiot. Why was she even friends with him?

Nevertheless, her patience only lasted the time she changed out of her work clothes into a loose T-shirt she had picked from the plus size Men’s section back home – the only ones that hung on her like the baby-blue shirt Julia Roberts sported in Notting Hill the morning after she slept with Hugh Grant. She smiled sheepishly when she realized how firmly the image was imprinted in her head and how unfixable her filminess really was. Once snuggled into the thick white duvet, the heating in her room working overtime to fight the frost of the world outside, she took exactly two minutes to curse herself for closing the chat window with Arjun without saving the link and then quickly jumped to YouTube to search for the title she wouldn’t forget anytime soon.

The video came on quickly and twinkled into her ears before punching her gut with a force too strong for a body tired and a heart desperately working to save itself.

There he was, in the center of a carefully arranged set up of singers forming the chorus, the instrumentalists – him on the acoustic guitar and another on an electric one.

And beside him was Nishant-Sir, his face brilliantly plump, head full of curly hair that gave him the appearance of a maestro. Her heart warmed immediately at the sight. Why had she lost touch with this person, she wondered? Was it Arjun’s comment about Nishant-Sir having had feelings for her? No, she concluded. She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her. Arjun, in fact was the only one to have survived. And it was largely to his own credit. After all, the truth was that if Arjun had not shown up at the station when she was first leaving for Bangalore, she might never have reached out to him of her own accord.

AV-Sir, however, had no such issues clearly. It was ten years later, more than that infact, and he was still singing with Nishant Kumar Pathak. And were they singing!

The guitar strummed against his fingers, even as the keyboard mimicked the accordion and merged into the notes.

And it was Arnav who started, his fingers twisting against the strings on one end and the pick at the other.

Paani da, rang vekh ke

Paani da, rang vekh ke

Paani da, rang vekh ke

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

The chorus finished the line and waited for the other voice to pick the song up as AV, shrugged at Nishant-Sir.

Maahiya na aaya mera, maahiya na aaya

Maahiya na aaya mera, maahiya na aaya

Raanjhana na aaya mera, maahiya na aaya

Maahiya na aaya mera, raanjhana na aaya

And Arnav took over again.

Akhaan da, noor vekh ke

Akhaan da, noor vekh ke

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

As the background music stilled for a second, in a perfect imitation of the original – which not surprisingly Khushi knew as well as those singing on the screen seemed to. And Nishant-Sir picked up once again, his slightly sufi voice blending in effortlessly with Arnav’s more playback-ish voice

Kamli ho gayi tere bina, aaja raanjhan mere

Kamli ho gayi tere bina, aaja raanjhan mere

Baarish barkha sab kuch beh gayi, aaya nahi jind mere

Baarish barkha sab kuch beh gayi, aaya nahi jind mere

The intensity of Nishant-Sir’s voice was still as stinging as it was when she first heard his Teri Deewani rendition. And though in the moment, it had been her fledgling feelings for Arnav that she had associated with that song, over the years, it was Nishant-Sir she thought of fondly when she heard strains of it playing in buses and tea-shops.

Akhaan da, noor vekh ke

Akhaan da, noor vekh ke

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

The guitars stopped and stummed in all strings for a second as the camera panned and then zoomed into Arnav’s face, the lights shimmering behind his head like a halo. His eyes glowed unfettered by glasses and his face gleamed in yearning that she had deliberately forgotten.

Kothe utte baihke, ankhiyaan milaunde

Na jaana humein tu kabhi chhod

Tere utte marda, pyaar tenu karda

Milega tujhe na koi aur

Her heart spun around her spine in an axis of heartache as the screen now focused on his eyes alone and nothing else. The moment was short, so short that with anyone else, she might not even have noticed the little movement. This was a video, she reminded herself even as she told herself to breathe. He wasn’t singing for someone, especially for her. And the words….they were coincidental. She might have been the one to leave. She might have been the one to never find another. But…it was not possible. Five years was a long time. It was a LONG time, more than most couples her age now had together.

Tu bhi aa, sabko chhod ke,

Tu bhi aa, sabko chhod ke,

Meri, ankhiyaanch hanju rudd de

Her eyes filled suddenly, the years of guilt and wondering whether she had been right or wrong, squeezing her chest painfully enough to make her want to forget about her no crying alone or otherwise rule.

Now Nishant-Sir and AV looked at each other and sang together, a small smile on both their lips as the camera zoomed out and panned to all the chorus and instrumentalists by turn as the song came to an end and the group together in pre-arranged sync.

Paani da, rang vekh ke

Paani da, rang vekh ke

Paani da, Rang vekh ke

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

Aankhiyaanch, hanju rudd de

The lights deemed one by one and eventually blanked the screen out as the music dimmed and came to a stop. And once again, the silence in her room screamed in her ears.

She flipped laptop close and threw it aside, her eyelashes sweeping against her cheeks in a damp trail of self-inflicted destiny as she absently reached out to her right and plunged her room into darkness with the flick of a button.

——————

The bunch of keys remained lying hapless and unattended on the small wooden desk in her room for the better part of the night and next morning. Breakfast was a hurried affair when she woke up in a haste close to closing time. After breakfast, Khushi sauntered back to the room, taking the straight path instead of a roundabout around the parking lot, just to avoid running into Arnav – after all he did mention that he would be out only starting afternoon. The hours rolled by slower than she had ever experienced in her lifetime. She – who couldn’t ever have enough time to herself to do what she most wanted – was bored by the time it was two in the afternoon. Reruns of House MD held little appeal. Friends was cheerful to indulge in. Maggi made lunch and lifted her spirits a little but by early evening, though it was already dark, the thought of making a Walmart trip began to sound very appealing. She could, of course, go to the little gym in the Inn and work some of her nervous energy out. But then, what kind of sensible person would that make her?

So, around five in the evening, she had a bath, got dressed and layered herself with the sole aim of making her first solo driving trip in the US, even if it was only a mile of driving in all. Thankfully, over the week, Arnav had been anal enough to force her to drive at least one way every day – usually in the morning.

And hour later, she was back in the room, having successfully completed her solo trip to Walmart. She felt a sense of accomplishment unparalleled by those she had actively spent more time and effort on. She chuckled to herself as she placed the flimsy white bag full of completely unnecessary buying. And to think she had always claimed she was one untouched by retail therapy. Perhaps given the right circumstances, everyone was…

The sharp buzz of her phone rudely interrupted the thought. She looked at the digital alarm by the bed and frowned. It was still too early in India for anyone to call her. So she hurried to pick her phone up and was even more surprised to see a local Detroit code flashing on the screen.

Arnav? She took a deep breath and answered the call with a tentative “Hello”

“Kaveri?”

She let out a deep breath. Not Arnav. And no, she wasn’t disappointed. Just incredibly confused. Who could possibly call her here on her US number? And then the thought occureed in flash of disappointment. Work! It had to be! Dammit. Served her right for complaining about being bored.

“Yes?” She answered and crossed her fingers and toes. Please, Shiv-ji, let it not be work.

“How are you?”

She frowned. What was this? “I’m good. Who’s this?”

There was a small chuckle on the other side. Too soft. “You didn’t recognize me, of course.”

Err… “No,” She said half defensively and then chided herself. Why was she feeling stupid? The person who was doing this should be feeling idiotic. Who did this? “Who is this?” She asked again, her voice now a lot sterner than it had been.

Chuckles followed once again, this time louder and somewhat familiar. “I know it’s been almost a decade but…okay answer this – did you finally get classical music training or not?”

The lights came on in her head not unlike a comic book. She could literally picture the thought cloud above her head bursting with light as bulb flickered to life. A smile split on to her face in warmth she couldn’t believe she was capable of for someone she hadn’t seen in – he was right – almost a decade. “Nishant-Sir? Is that you?”

This time the laughter was unmistakable – still hesitant and too soft. How had she not placed him immediately? It was so obvious. And so uncanny. Just last night was the first time she’d seen Nishant-Sir in a decade and now…

“Chalo, thank God! It’s not all bad yet,” He was saying, still chuckling.

Khushi’s smile widened. “This is such a surprise. How…” She shook her head, “How did you get my number? How did you even know I am in the US and…how come you are here too? Arjun? Did he tell you? I didn’t even know he was in touch…”

“This must have been the most Ive heard you speak ever, Kaveri. Stop, stop.”

Khushi chuckled and sat down on the bed. He was right. And she was surprised by herself.

“I live here – in Detroit. The otherside of town from where you are but the same town nevertheless.”

“Oh really? You do? That’s such a coincidence.”

“It’s about to get weirder.”

Khushi frowned bemusedly. “Matlab?”

“Matlab, I work with Wyatt Motors. In the R&D function. I head the Vehicle design group.”

“Oh wow! That is just so cool.” Khushi said as genuine awe filled her mouth. He must be very good at what he did to work with Wyatt’s R&D. And Vehicle Desig…Now here was someone who was using his engineering degree well.

“Cool is having AV tell me that IE-V’s famous first year mech girl is in Detroit and as a hot-shot consultant. Can you believe he is still such a mystery man – he must have known for what,” The phone seemed to shuffle on the other end as his voice became dimmer, “You’ve known for at least a month, AV? And you tell me now and you don’t tell her at all.”

Arnav. Of course. Suddenly so much seemed to make sense. Nishant-Sir’s connections must have helped Arnav make his own connections at Wyatt. He stayed here for months – he had to have a social life. And the music video that she had seen last night…

“Anyway, I am so glad AV told me when he did. This weekend is all gone. But let’s meet next weekend? AV usually comes down and stays with us. You should come with him next time.”

She didn’t know what to say. Saying no was rude. And saying yes was dangerous. She found herself saying something non-committal even as Nishant Kumar Pathak restated how happy he was to have connected with her after so many years – a declaration she resoundingly reciprocated. They spoke for a few more minutes – mostly about Arjun and how Nishant and Arjun had infact been in touch uncharacteristically sporadically over the years and that he hadn’t spoken to Arjun in almost two years – the time that he had made the transition to Wyatt from another auto-maker in the city. The call ended with Nishant-Sir re-extending the invitation for her to join Arnav the next time he made his usual weekend trip.

Later that night, she watched the Pani Da Rang video again and once more after that, this time focusing as much on Nishant-Sir as she did on Arnav. She smiled to herself as the second viewing came to an end and as YouTube prompted another user video which she decided against watching. What all was this man capable of? Music videos? In addition to being a top-performing consultant and as busy as she knew client-facing management consultants were.

And how absolutely surreal would it be to take Nishant-Sir up on his offer for her to visit. She decided she would go if the invitation came about again closer to the end of the week. Yes. She would go. She didn’t know whether the decision would last till it was actually time to execute but she owed it to her eighteen year old self to go meet these people again. Perhaps, Shiv-ji really was giving her the closure she was so sure she didn’t need.

River Song, Music and Lyrics

Song Title: Naam Gum Jaayega

Album: Kinara

Singer(s): Lata Mangeshkar, Bhupendra

Music: R. D. Burman

Lyrics: Gulzar

 

Jo guzar gayi, kal ki baat thi

Umrh toh nahi, ek raat thi

Raat ka sira agar, phir mile kahin

Meri awaaz hi pehchaan hai

Gar yaad rahe

 

 

Note:

  1. Thank you all for reading and for waiting so patiently as I deal with a rather cruel real world.
  2. Next Update: Monday, May 1, 2017 late night IST
  3. While I ask you to wait, might I also suggest a couple of pieces of sheer brilliance, toe curling, intense and everything we love about romantic fiction.
    1. Begin Again by chotidesi (Meena Narayan): This is not Fan-fiction but please don’t let that stop you from diving right in. Not to be missed and the best way to encourage a former fan-fiction writer from amongst us! She just posted Chapter Twenty a couple days ago and I hope (I want to say I am sure) that she will see this through.
    2. One Day At A Time by Sohni: This one is from our very own Appu / Sohniye. Set in the early-mid 90s, this one is a toe curling riot of colors – friendship, love and romance. With Chapter Ten posted earlier this week, the story is poised to take that dive that plunges readers right into the depths of story-telling. Her first outing as an author, she says. I am inclined to distrust her – how can debuts be this well done? (I hope to be able to share another debut as soon as she hits her Chapter Ten mark :))

 

 

407 thoughts on “Chapter Nine: In (Full?) Circles

    1. Tere utte marda, pyaar tenu karda
      Milega tujhe na koi aur
      😍😍
      Yes! Yes! KKG this is AV’s dil ki pukaar – ab toh suno naa suno naa sunlo naa 😉😊

      Liked by 20 people

        1. Yes, it has! I missed River and it’s nivaasis! Now I am back n ready to mingle! 😊🤗

          I am still in shock that I beat Nivi at fastest finger!😳

          Liked by 14 people

    2. “Music is therapy. Music moves people. It connects people in ways that no other medium can. It pulls heart strings. It acts as medicine.”

      Never have truer words been said. It is music that has kept AV sane for the last five year. His stoic façade ably conceals the maelstrom of emotions swirling inside him, but every now and then they escape the prison of his heart to reveal themselves…be it in the gut wrenching yearning that glazes his sun-kissed irises or in the unguarded flicker of his steady gaze. He is adept at reading Khushi and the myriad expressions that flash across her expressive face; her sulks amuse him but her skittish behavior annoys him which manifests itself in his cold withdrawal.

      Khushi admires the public persona of Senior Manager Arnav Varun, but she is clueless about the man behind the image. I agree with her thinking “This was not AV-Sir. This was not even Arnav. This was AV – Senior Manager, Strategy; Project Lead for Wyatt Motors’s Emerging Markets Entry Strategy assignment being delivered by A&M Consulting at their world headquarters. She knew nothing of this man except that he was a professional superstar.”; but I do not agree with “And that was enough.” She needs to get to know him, to understand the present day AV. She can’t allow herself to become a victim of all the “what ifs” that make her heart clench with guilt! She has to stop thinking of worst case scenarios and take a leap of faith!

      The first viewing of the YouTube video and the fleeting glimpse of that “unnamed emotion” in AV’s eyes left her with damp eyes and a heavy heart. The surprise phone call from Nishant-Sir and their conversation brightened her face and brought a happy glow to her heart which made her second and third viewing of the video a pleasant experience. I think she is ready to welcome old friends and suppressed memories back into her life…Life is offering her a second chance at love with the man who is firmly entrenched in her heart and it’s time she grabbed this opportunity with both hands.

      Nishant Kumar Pathak – Head of Vehicle Design at Wyatt Motors…Impressive! 👏🏻Nishant-Sir has done very well for himself both professionally and personally (hoping that the “us” alludes to a wife or girlfriend). I hope that Khushi hits it off with NK’s significant other…She needs a female friend in Detroit – someone with similar interests and maybe the one who will encourage her to indulge in a little “real” retail therapy (VS/Pink)!😉

      Her visits to NK’s home will also provide her with the much needed personal time with AV, allow her to observe the relaxed, informal man socializing, crooning songs and hopefully all this will help her correctly decipher the expressions flitting across AV’s glowing eyes! 😉😊

      Meera, thank you for the update and the beautiful songs! 😘🤗 The re-entry of Nishant Pathak brings hope to my restless heart…hope that the day is not too far when Khushi/AV will verbalize the longings of their heart to each other! 😊

      Liked by 19 people

      1. I guess Nishant is also around 30..hoping he got married early nad has a toddler now.. AV playing with the kid might melt Kushi’s heart 😄

        Liked by 5 people

    1. This is like slow death. I mean that as one would say if I-die-now-I’ll-die-happy kinda way. But then I don’t want die absolutely, or only want it so much so that I can count those breaths and hold onto them until you to steal them away the next time. This is seduction. It’s insanity.

      I like that little pinch of jealousy. She didn’t need it to strengthen truths but it’s there and it says something. She can’t cook to save her life and he only does it sometimes. That’s why the both of them need to have a meal outside. (Yes, even if she’s been sharing all the ones in Detroit with him). A movie. A picnic. A date. I won’t say the word but it’ll be just the same.

      I want to know what flickered through his eyes as he passed her the keys. Want being a small word.

      And the video! Who wouldn’t have tears line the hold of the eyes, when he said like that. Sang it like that. Just like that. Sigh.
      He meant it. There’s no doubt he meant it. She’s shaking it away so that she can’t see.
      There’s a little guilt sedimented after all these years whenever​ she looks back to the time she walked away. I wish she’d stop burdening herself. And I feel it now more than ever before, despite it all, she’ll be the one to take a step towards him this time. There’s some of twisted justice in that.

      I was just musing while reading the part involving the video, what it would be to have Nishant back into her world and lo behold, the man’s calling her and sharing laughter. She was fond of him then, she’s fond of him now too. All smiles.

      Next week, please come quickly. For us and in Detroit too.
      Do I even have to say it? Marvel.

      I feel like those scheming aunties at every shaadi while I feel this unnatural need to demand Nishant Kumar Pathak’s bio-data for scrutiny. Family, single, married, Kids? Tell us more.
      Wonder if Nishant will play Cupid if he’s not too busy standing in line this time around?

      PS: Thanks for the video. Really.

      PPS: Plump you say?

      PPPS: What will happen if Nishant decides to confess certain things to Kaveri?

      — He’ll become Nishant Kumar Visphotak!

      Liked by 28 people

        1. P, green monsters are great. But only as long as the other party knows it’s fake. Someone else in picture comes with too many risks. Even if a sham, who can stop a woman from crocheting her dreams? We’re talking about an oblivious AV. A second is what it takes. With you there. If there comes a need for a stretcher, I’ll book two. :D

          I hope NK is match-making AV with Khushi, if at all he is. We can do without these kinds of Visphotak. :p

          Liked by 4 people

      1. Nivi I agree that this time around it will be KKG taking the first step!

        I too want to know what is that something elusive that glimmers in AV’s eyes each time he looks at her?!?! Longing or something else?

        I think Mr. Pathak is a happily married man! 😉

        How many Cupid’s does our girl need! 🙄 The green-eyed monster did tear its head fleetingly when AV mentioned he had plans for the weekend! 😉

        I am hoping that she will get a little envious when she sees NK enjoying wedded bliss…maybe a little wistful too thinking of all her wasted, lonely years! 😉😊

        Liked by 17 people

        1. She’s already plagued with what ifs. This meet with NK will be bittersweet?

          I want to know who’s Mrs. Pathak is Divs. Someone we know? And is there a toddler who’s already started the music training? :D We’ll know if he/she cries with the right aalaap and in the right shruthi.

          Liked by 4 people

          1. Nivi, Khushi needs to free herself from the shackles of “what ifs”, listen to what her heart desires and take a leap of faith! 😊

            I have this unshakable feeling that pretty Divya Sahay is Nishant Pathak’s significant other! 😁

            An adorable curly haired moppet with a melodious warble?!? 😄 This has to be a true blue Sahay/Pathak progeny! 😉😂

            Liked by 3 people

    1. Just when we were all speculating about the Youtube video capturing moments from the real Aarohan, you throw us a curve ball by showing a recent music video of the men with voice of gold. But I love this song, ever since I heard it first time in the movie. And the part where the camera zooms in on his eyes and she sees his yearning – Haye!!!!!!! You must have enjoyed writing it – isn’t it? :D

      So is NK single still???? Who is this ‘us’ he refers to – seems like his girlfriend/ wife? I am glad Khushi made the decision to join them the following week, and hope she sticks to it without finding any new excuses. This kind of company is so much better than non-stop TV and lonely shopping trips in Detroit :) Perhaps more music videos in the making soonish??? Looking forward to next week :)

      It was interesting to see that the repeat views of the video had not rendered her as miserable as the first viewing had. But her pain the first time was palpable. She is not only going to get her and AV killed in not a road accident, but also us with her self-imposed restraints.

      Waiting eagerly for the AV Interlude…. Jaldi please authorji!!!!!!!

      PS:

      1. How many times have I done it – closed a chat window without making a note of something important!
      2. So he cooks! Fantastic! Just what we need when she gets bored with Maagie :)
      3. I can understand the sense of accomplishment that goes with solo driving – it happened years ago with a tow-wheeler and more recently with the car. Especially after hearing so much about how pathetic a driver I am :D

      Liked by 19 people

                1. Hahahahahhahahahahhaha oh if you’ve read any of my work – you’d know that ;) I’ve been known to skip beds and breakfasts too you know. Just saying ;)

                  Liked by 11 people

                    1. Me will be second, since you already claimed the first spot ;-) Talking about bed’n’breakfast: Meera, at least let AV walk KKG up to her room.. baaki assumptions hum pe chod do… ahem ahem!!

                      Liked by 8 people

              1. I think she does eats eggs. Remember she was reaching for the scrambled eggs at the Inn’s breakfast before AV stopped her saying they were not “real” but made from a concoction in a carton! 🙂

                Liked by 8 people

    1. Paani Da.. one more song touched by you which will never be the same again. The next time I hear it, I will think of him! Incidentally, in an interview (the only one I’ve have ever watched in IPK days) Barun had said that this was his favourite song and I had not heard it at that time, but the fan in me had googled it, and I was hooked. :D I love this song for many reasons now! :D
      And I had thought nothing would trump Behne De!! :)

      The words he sang touched my heart and I could feel his pain. Where is this unearthly patience coming from Shivji? Such unnatural restraint, and for so many years!! God, this is a hell! What can I say! There had to be a time in the last five years where he realised that she was the one. He might not be in a position to pinpoint the exact day or the moment, but he did realise it! But from then on, it has just been an endless wait.. for what…he doesn’t know. and won’t know… as he is never sure of what exactly she wants from him!

      “Good night.” He said softly as her hands closed around the keys and his fell away without contact with her skin.
      “Good night.” She whispered with a half smile which he didn’t return.
      – So deliberate! So careful! Without contact with her skin. A smile which he didn’t return. Almost like there is a tinge of anger in him which resurfaces unexpectedly at times. That third phone call, I now believe, has pushed him further away. He didn’t mention NK to her. He didn’t mention anything to her. So much indifference, dear god, I don’t know what to say!

      I step out of my comfort zone and wonder. What is it that makes this man “stay” in love with her over all these years? I understand that he was not insanely in love with her, but he had felt something. And that something was potent enough to hold his heart for five(ten!) years. He is aware that she had chosen to walk away from him, had slammed the doors on his face when he tried to get in touch with her again, but he still couldn’t let go. I am still wondering cus I don’t have the answers!

      She had had his heart and let’s assume she has it even now. But the distance between them has only grown. From kissing her like there was no tomorrow at the camp until today, where they can’t manage a simple conversation without all that awkwardness… uff they have so much to sort out!

      She is a complex individual riding high on insecurities even at this age and stage! Even now she is telling herself that he does not have feelings for her, that he didn’t sing for her. Even now she takes his indifference as the absolute truth and prefers not to challenge it. When she is so sure that she doesn’t matter to him, how the hell is she going to take a step forward, I don’t know! He won’t relent (Which I’m sure has been her doing), and she won’t initiate (Cus she’s still unsure of his feelings for her!). A bloody impasse!

      And this is where I think NK ji comes in. I was so happy because he came back! :) He might just be the person to turn this whole thing around. Mr Trigger Pathak! He is the broken link to their past. He will make her sing “Teri Deewani” and make him sing “Mujhe raat din bas mujhe….”. He will force them to live those days again and make them experience those feelings which have been diligently locked away in some corner of their heart. He will bring music back into their life. It had bound them together then, and it will bind them together again(Sounds like a line from the movie ‘Abhimaan’!) He will talk about Arnav and the little things he knew about him, providing her with an insight into his life in those days. If there is any possibility that NK and Khushi have a candid chat, she might just discover Arnav a bit more, and hopefully in a new light.

      Things I noticed –
      -How Arnav hasn’t let go of singing…music. It is still his passion and something that has held him together for so many years. Just goes to show how wrong his relationship with Saira was because this is something that mattered a lot to him.
      She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her. – This hit the core of my heart. Lethal blow Meeru. You can’t put it out so flatly like that :( It’s painful.
      Her heart spun around her spine in an axis of heartache as the screen now focused on his eyes alone and nothing else. – Loved that line :)

      Loved loved loved the update. Let’s, please, skip the work week ahead and jump directly to the next weekend, pretty please :P I want to meet the plump Nishant Sir asap! :D Meko jam session chahiye between these three! It has been a while since Kavi sang something :)

      And now.. the most important bit –
      Thank you for that lovely note, thank you so so much! Your words, your encouragement and now this..I feel so selfish, you keep giving and I keep taking. I wish there was a better way to thank you Meeru. I’ll just say Thank you once again for everything… Love you. :)

      Liked by 20 people

      1. Sohniye 😘
        That third phone call. Did he tell her it was love all along, but she, the betrayal & hurt she had felt making her scared probably to give in, shuts the door. And now it pinches her that decision.
        The music is such an intrinsic part of him, and maybe it also makes him feel that connection with her, even after all that happened, and all the time that has passed.

        Liked by 17 people

        1. So well said, Sohni. I too hope NK Sir will play the catalyst in finally moving them inextricably closer. Cannot wait to see what he will do…..Arnav is so obviously hurting really bad, that alone explains the indifference. I disagree about him not being insanely in love with her five years ago at The River….he always knew the intensity of his love…it is Her Highness Khushi Kaveri Gupta that decides to turn tail and run….goodness, i am so livid with that girl. Hope NK has more luck than AV did proving the point to her. AV’s yearning through that memorable song….Paanni da….so appropriate for this jam session between two college mates….and yes, certainly for Arnav his music has been a vehicle for his deepest thoughts, his soul, his quintessence….

          Will get around to reading you story some day soon and let you know my thoughts, Asli duniya is a menace!

          Liked by 14 people

      2. – She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her – Agree with you – It touched my heart too….

        – Trigger Pathak :D ROFL…. even I think there is more music in the pipeline to bring these two together – yaayyy – seems to be the only way – isn’t it?!!!

        Liked by 15 people

          1. She probably told him to move on and forget about her as there can never be a “them”! 😐No wonder her heart constricts with guilt each time she sees that ephemeral “unnamed emotion” in AV’s eyes! 😕

            Liked by 6 people

            1. It’s almost like she is testing herself Divz. How much more can she endure? I know she has issues but how much more can she roast herself in this really horrible place of knowing that she loves him but not wanting to do anything about it! 🙁

              Let’s keep AV aside for a moment, the point is .. errr…. ummm..nah, there is no point in anything if he is kept aside 😋 Forgot what I was going to say .. so forget what I said 😁😋

              Liked by 6 people

              1. We can’t keep AV aside love! AV nahin toh story nahin! 😉😁
                The problem with Khushi is that she is unable to separate the persona from the man. The persona is unattainable in her eyes! She has to look beyond the image and understand the living, breathing red-blooded man AV! 😊

                She is eager to meet up with NK which means revisiting the past! I think she is ready to let go of her painful memories and break free from the fetters of indecisiveness and denial!

                She will be able to observe and better understand (🤞🏻🤞🏻) AV in his informal avatar when she spends time with him driving to/from NK’s on weekends, see an affable AV socialize, sing with NK and the band, probably receive more compliments from NK and maybe AV as well! This should make her realize that she is AV’s equal and this man with sun-kissed irises who sings “Behene de”, “Paani da” and “Main yahaan hoon” croons these with only her in mind and that she “deserves” to have this man in her life! 😊

                Liked by 6 people

                1. Beautiful D!!! Seeing the man behind the glorious persona that outshines everything else!!! Seeing him for his troubles, challenges, vulnerabilitites as well on top of everything else that he excels at….

                  I feel that that vulnerability that was on display when he was practicing for the interview was what made her bold… made her realize that she could offer something to him… before that famous question ” is there anyone else” popped out :)

                  Liked by 6 people

                  1. Bingo Anu! 😘🤗 Khushi needs to be reminded that AV is the same carefree, amiable, sensitive man under that well fitted business suit and is her equal! Her weekend visits to NK’s home will re-acquaint her with this informal AV she has not seen since Camp R. 😊

                    I have this vision in my head of a casually attired, relaxed AV fine tuning his guitar, bantering with NK and others when he suddenly throws his head back in a loud guffaw, making Khushi’s breath hitch as she stares unblinkingly at this uncommon sight. A laughing AV looks incredibly handsome, the lines in his face softened, the hard set to his mouth relaxed and his rich laughter as soothing as the ocean breeze, making the butterflies in Khushi’s belly spin around in a tipsy dance! 😍

                    Liked by 6 people

          2. You are right dear.. his behavior is a result of their last conversation 4 years ago. You described it well in of our responses to someone… “give me space.. stay away from me” etc.

            Liked by 6 people

      3. Sohniye, meko bhi jam session mangta! 😉😁
        I want KKG to sing “Iss Deewane” with NK and AV to sing “Dilbar Mere” 😍😍

        Like you, I too felt a whisper of unease unfurl in my heart as I read – “She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her.” 😯

        Liked by 13 people

      4. “wow” to ur comments… the very famous 3rd call. I dont know how many calls my husband had made before i said yes.. but i know by heart how many calls AV made..and the 3rd one is haunting me. Ok.. Yet he s still a mystery to me.
        U R right abt Khushi thinking and analysing about AV..I mean if I had analysed my life changing/ important things, half the way she does..i would have been a quite hot shot con with patience. I tght I was kind of overanalysing and serious person b4 Khushi came into pic. Now I have confirmed affirmed and decided tht I’m an enthu potato/ motor mouth😃..

        Liked by 12 people

      5. Lovely Appu! Said something similar in my comment too. She is insecure and complex and he is seething behind the stone like facade..wonder how these two are ever going to get together 🙄
        Now I am wondering if the pain of her rejection has embedded itself so deeply that he is unable to let go. Complicated!

        Liked by 11 people

          1. Locking them up in a room with no laptops or cell phones will work best! 😁
            Yeh do ek kamre mein band ho aur chaabi kho jaaye
            AV ke nainon ki bhool bhulaiyan mein Khushi kho jaaye…
            😉😂

            Liked by 8 people

      6. Appy 😘

        My tone maybe direct here, but you’ll understand I know 🙂

        as he is never sure of what exactly she wants from him! – adding my thoughts to this line. He knows exactly what she wants from him. That is why the indifference, protectiveness and fear that keeps resurfacing in his eyes and voice. He walked away from river giving her what she wanted but he couldn’t get away from her thoughts I think, behne de and Paani da are the his side. Since the college days, he had the same feelings, he connected to her, he felt the same and that is why he wants her, not ready to let go of her.

        She is a complex individual riding high on insecurities even at this age and stage! – AV is natural at reading people, Khushi maybe not so well because of her nature of being in her own world apart from when required. How can she base everything upon the songs, it’s a long time. It’s not insecurities, not anymore. This time it is more to do with her understanding the pull towards him, the sync between them. She observing him at the hotel, one step in the direction of knowing AV, these things will help her eventually. For now it’s knowing and understanding him which Khushi never got to….

        Liked by 16 people

        1. Yes I understand what you say …I think I do Lavz :P

          Ref to your first para – You know what he knows? He knows she has feelings for him. And he knows she doesn’t want to do anything about it. He knows that she has asked him to bugger off. He knows she has very little faith in him and his feelings for her(aarohan night kaand!). He knows he’s hurt her. He knows she is carrying that hurt for a long time. And when he wanted to do something about it, he called her up…thrice! But he knows that she is not willing to let go of that hurt. He knows she doesn’t want to do anything about this weird situation that they are in.

          So meri jaan.. I know what he knows! The problem is he doesn’t know what she wants from him. Oh but, he does knows what she doesn’t want from him as well!! :P
          At the moment its quite evident that she doesn’t want to have breakfast with him or doesn’t want to socialise with him or doesn’t wantto spend a single minute with him! :P

          I try to see her from his POV…..a petulant child? immature?fear? worry? anxiety? embarrassment? hurt? lost? worried? abra ka dabra? dunno! But he is okay with it. He is around. He is there, caring for her, trying to make her stay comfortable, providing her information which she hasn’t an inkling of because she prefers staying in her room! (oh kudos for that first round at Walmart though!)

          Since the college days, he had the same feelings, he connected to her, he felt the same and that is why he wants her, not ready to let go of her. – He never had her, so ‘not let go of her’ doesn’t hold Lavz. She didn’t allow it. She ran away. She ran away at the river. She ran away from the phone calls. She ran away from any connections or talks about him. And now she is running away from the path that he will take for the breakfasts!!! Shivji!

          Na chhod paa rahi hain, na pakad paa rahi hain. Buuri phasi re jaana.

          How can she base everything upon the songs, it’s a long time. – She will have to settle for the songs Lavy cus she has cut him off from any other form of communication. He would love to talk! But alas! Shes made the tough choice. She will have to live with it.

          For now, it’s knowing and understanding him which Khushi never got to…. – same as above :P She didn’t give him a chance! He tried. Yes he did! :(

          Im not saying she is right or wrong jaana, all I say is, jo ho raha uske saath, uski marzi se ho raha hain. And She has asked for the wall that he has drawn in front of them. Now he lives by it. No one can do anything.

          NK. Thats my only hope now. :(

          Liked by 13 people

          1. Even if she has drawn up the wall, bottom line they are in sync, attuned to each other. He wants her, he’ll ask her one more time and he is exactly doing that in so many ways. The time, the place and situations everything is a hope for both of them here after :)

            PS: nobody is right or wrong agreed neither AV nor Khushi 😛😁

            Liked by 9 people

    1. She shivers…his eyes flickers…did he want to ask her if she was cold? But did not. Arnav is considerate…did he take a cab/crosstown bus to get to NK house…and left the car for her? It seems so. Was that what forced him to tell NK about KK being in Detroit? He does not talk about her! Everything is inder wrap!
      What a pleasant surprise NK…the now plump NK is married ( most probably…signs of it :)…and do the duo have a band…they sing together? Arnav loves singing ( know at least two friends who do this here) !

      KK she is very different. Like she said if Arjun had not tried..she would have let the friendship go…and not just because of what happened in the camp…she does not want to make any effort. Wonder what will be required to shake her off this inertia? She has a health issue…but that is not the driver for excercise but Raagini is ! Like I said she is different…Arnav has his work cut out for him…what will it take for her to snap out of this lazy living?
      Ps. The you tube song…and Arnav’s longing….a trigger?
      Ps1. Trio singing next weekend?

      Liked by 20 people

          1. Mentioning NK will mean revisiting the past, which both refrain from talking about. Both strive at keeping their conversation light and impersonal. Dono adiyal hain! 😉😁

            Liked by 13 people

          2. Does not want to mention anything or anyone they both used to know! Almost like he doesn’t want to own up to knowing her form before..except of course, that he calls her Khushi!

            Liked by 10 people

            1. Lol..on Khushi. I think it is like there is do much of her dicta he will take. It is likr “You are my khushi…and I will call you Khushi”. Ajeeb ladki hain….the work is cut out for him.

              Liked by 10 people

      1. Khushi has her work cut out too..It’s hard to read a man like him!
        Maybe because of lack of communication between them feels like the work between them. The more they are around each other, they’ll know the strengths and weaknesses. It’s not all Khushi I mean to say 😁

        Lazy living, subjective. Not everyone is perfect some things come easily and some through struggle. Cest la vie!

        Liked by 9 people

    1. Nishant Sir ki entry……I am speechless to see how you have woven such a complex web. Me think with stubborn Khushi, sabko bahut papad belne pad rahe hain, including writersahiba. Kaise realize karvaooooo…;)
      So happy to see that Arnav is still connected to his first love Music, and spends weekends over them. A hobby is such a must, am sure it helped him deal with the free time without Khushi.
      Can’t wait for the khulaasa about the third call, am sure Arnav is thinking kitna control aur kitna control. He is as edgy around her as she is. Bolna nahi allowed hain, bataana nahi allowed hain, kuch karna hi allowed nahi hain as per Khushi’s orders. Poor thing is just respecting her wishes.
      This is like the calm before the storm.
      I do connect with Khushi on this, “She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her.” Did that in my younger days, still have to work very hard to stay in touch, so have reminders on my calendar. ;)
      Waiting for the Visphotak meeting…..
      Thank you once again for such a beautiful chapter, despite your hectic AD. Take care!! Salute’

      Liked by 12 people

      1. “She was the kind of person who let people go irrespective of how important they were to her.” – I see it too, I am built like that, but time has taught me few things and Khushi will get there too. Not easy definitely!

        Liked by 9 people

              1. Don’t ask!! Its just life as usual actually but I have realised that if I try to keep up with rest of life, nadiya kinare time becomes a really scarce commodity. Ironically when I had a slack period, the nadiya was not flowing. 😀 Of course I could always let thing slide and indulge myself……😛. Will do that one of these days and catch up with all the discussions on the last few chapters……even if it takes me forever (the way it’s been)😀. I miss this place and all of you……it’s addictive and my little bit of self-indulgence.

                Liked by 3 people

    1. When will Khushi come out of self imposed prison ? This girl will drive AV nuts . The man is suffering , that is why the indifference .
      He had offered Khushi to take for breakfast , shouldn’t she use this opportunity 😐 like Always she chose to run away
      .
      Pani da song is a very beautiful , from now onwards I am going to imagine AV singing this with guitar . NK is still in touch with AV in music as well as carrier . Like all the fellow readers I thought the you tube video link is from Aarohan night 😘

      NK has invited Khushi to spend the weekend in his place .May be he is married .Eager to know about him .Will he drill some sense into Khushi’s thick brain . Hope Khushi doesn’t chicken out this time .

      Khushi has accomplished driving alone for a mile , that is really a good change .
      I badly need AV’s Pov meera . Need to know what he thinks , how he feels .

      Awesome chapter

      Liked by 7 people

  1. Great update I was expecting them to talk it out this weekend and I guess it’s not going to happen very soon autherji should be having a different altogether. But it was interesting Khushi should speak I think that will resolve most of her amity. Can’t wait for 1st may.

    Liked by 7 people

    1. The first ever compliment from AV that Khushi is here as a hot-shot consultant meaning an exceptional professional to work with. She is here because of her skills and her intelligence. He considers her professionally impressive, Khushi should revisit this dialogue once again 😊

      AV observes a lot since the beginning, he reads people to understand. It comes naturally to him, because of this trait even though not speaking to Khushi a lot, he knows her to a great extent. Again in the update, it was clear that he was silent and was being observant as always, learning about his people :)

      All AV’s actions affirm that he wants Khushi to be independent in a way. She is reluctant and surely anyone in her place would behave the same being in a new place but he wants her to learn and experience things. He giving her the car keys was a quick decision although he was little apprehensive to leave her alone over the weekend I think. Everything he does seems like as if there is the thought behind it and he is following a route to reach a goal. His heart and brain are in sync and I believe it’s solely him!

      Tere utte marda, pyaar tenu karda
      Milega tujhe na koi aur
      – This and Behne de are pointers to his side of the pain and yearning but still, it’s not the whole impact on Khushi. Hard to read and understand the reasons behind a song and yes since it’s a long time, it cannot be digested by Khushi until there is a talk between them.

      The damp trail on Khushi’s cheeks did pain me. She knows it is a self-inflicted destiny but she also knows the circumstance she was in when she took the decision. Years probably have made it easier for her to stack things away, following “out of sight out of mind” logic but being in close proximity and connected links, things are becoming hard and revisiting her past and the decision is inescapable I think. Though she thinks, it will help her move on and give her a closure if she sustains through the eight weeks but!

      NK in Detroit is a pleasant surprise. I did think that the video probably was after the river camp (it was one among my n options 😆), makes sense the boys resumed their passion for singing. NK and family will sure be a good break for Khushi after slogging and staying at the Inn for two weeks at a stretch. Hopefully, she’ll join AV next weekend if not for anything else than getting away from the Inn.

      AV was away but his heart was at the Inn I think! he wanted to know how she was fairing in his absence. She answering NK’s phone call must have relieved him from the constant thought of being away from her. The worry must have made him share an old month news now 💡(and also NK questioning about his transportation!).

      PS: One of my fav movies – Notting Hill and I do remember the soft blue shirt! And I also remember the morning after and the stairs of the apartment and the press in front of the house 😄 – haven’t watched it in ages though!

      For NK, AV must be a mystery man but he is becoming transparent with the updates, at least the senior head one 😈

      Liked by 17 people

      1. Stunning comment Lavs, honestly!!!! In some ways it seemed like a part of AV interlude to me. You have so very beautifully read between the lines to identify motivations behind his actions/ inaction. Things that I read with unseeing eyes amidst the chaos of lunchtime and sleepy eyes at night become more clearer with your comment. It is a reminder of what one will miss if they sont read the comments at the River!!!! 😘

        Liked by 10 people

        1. 😊 thankoo!!
          True Anu. With updates this time around senior head AV is becoming clearer for me, that’s what I think for now. Future update will tell more if I am missing the mark completely! 😄

          PS: Reading glasses didn’t help this time 😁

          Liked by 6 people

      2. Well said Lavz. Making her independent and not dependent on him…yes..hence making her drive from the first day itself.

        Also about Khushi been successful in parking her feelings till now…out of sight..out of mind. True test comes now.
        Ps. Hot shot consultant….does not sound like AV..that is NK. His compliment would be worded differently..more subtle. But NK has come a long way from IEV…did he not have difficulty in offering praises and was chided by AV 10 years ago ☺

        Liked by 7 people

        1. Probably @PS. But in a way something triggered NK to use the word, that tells me AV s thoughts of her professional work. Khushi is in all awe at his professional avatar, likewise I think 🙂

          Liked by 6 people

          1. That was a nice touch . Most of us change as we grow older..based on what life throws at us. NK has done well professionally…and am sure personally. The quiet ,reserved,guy AV..who spoke with ease with everybody has changed too. It will be interesting to read how AV interacts socially in a non business enviornment ( NK’s house)

            Liked by 7 people

            1. AV .. who spoke with ease with everybody has changed too – not really…the way he spoke to Shyam, the healthy comraderie and with Arjun it was back like I.E.- V days….professionally he has become sharp, his demeanor at work yes is different. Apart from Khushi, sociallyhe is same old AV I think…he was always fun around boys 😁

              Liked by 5 people

      3. Lavz, despite her being a hotshot consultant (NK has finally learned how to compliment a girl 😉), KKG continues to believe she is not good enough for AV.

        This was not AV-Sir. This was not even Arnav. This was AV – Senior Manager, Strategy; Project Lead for Wyatt Motors’s Emerging Markets Entry Strategy assignment being delivered by A&M Consulting at their world headquarters. She knew nothing of this man except that he was a professional superstar. And that was enough. This thinking clearly indicates that she still has him on a pedestal…She needs to look beyond the persona and get to know, to understand AV the man. The man who had waited patiently for her for the last 5 years.

        I think the weekend visits with NK will be beneficial for KKG, as it will provide her with an opportunity to share time with AV outside a professional space, hopefully glean some insight into AV the man, maybe even get to hear compliments on her professional achievements from both NK and AV. I hope and pray that her talks/discussions with NK make her realize that Arnav maybe hugely successful professionally, but like her he too has not moved on emotionally. I am optimistic that their jam sessions will make her aware of the yearning in his flickering eyes and the longing coloring the words he sings…for her! If this does not make her want to take a step towards him I dunno what else will! 😐

        Liked by 9 people

        1. One step at a time D, within a week sitting at the hotel with others she understood his silence.

          Yes being in close proximity things will be clear to her, she never got this time around him. So yes, she will know and understand through few things and few conversations gradually.

          Liked by 7 people

          1. Inteha ho gayi, intezaar ki
            Kab hogi khabar, iss ladki ko AV ke dharkanon ki
            Yeh hamein hain yakeen, bekhabar woh nahin
            Phir vajah kya hui, intezaar ki…
            😉😁

            Liked by 9 people

            1. Quoting Ghalib Saab 😊

              Masoom mohabbat ka bas itna fasaana hai
              Kaghaz ki haveli hai, barish ka zamana hai

              Kya rasm-e-mohabbat hai kya shart-e-zamaana hai
              Aawaz bhi zakmi hai, aur geet bhi gana hai

              Toota hua dil apna yoon unko dikhaana hai
              Bheegi hui aankhon se aik sher sunnana hai

              Us paar utarney ki ummeed naheen rakhna
              Kashti bhi puraani hai aur toofan bhi aana hai

              Naddani mere dil ki phir ishq ke zaad par hai
              Phir aag ka darya hai, phir doob hi jaana hai

              Yeh ishq nahin aasaan, bas itna samajh lijiye
              Aik aag ka darya hai, aur doob ke jaana hai

              Liked by 7 people

        2. Something came up in my mind while reading your comment. What if they have a singing session together when Khushi also visits next weekend? For old time’s sake, sorta one? I’d LOVE that!

          Liked by 3 people

      4. What we might see as silly and something that should not be held on to, can be painful and serious for someone else. Experiences are subjective. So it is with her. She took a decision borne out of hurt and betrayal, but it doesn’t mean she’s not plagued by what ifs. Someone who’s always in a way controlled, keeping her feelings and emotions in check, to know that what you had thought was your deepest feeling, was on show for someone. There is something about her feeling that he could read her better than anyone. And in a way that feeling was played with, its not wrong to feel like an utter fool in such a scenario. I think at her place her parents are not people who are very expressive. Isn’t there something about how she hugged them when they gave her a walkman, which is pretty unusual for her and them?
        He’s concerned but doesn’t want that to be obvious. It comes out as anger when she’s delayed by eight hours and he doesn’t know. Her first weekend alone, so the news that she’s in detroit working with him is given out to NK. He could’ve told NK when they joined, “hey remember kaveri and arjun they have joined a&m”. NK calling him the mystery man, I think every body knows that about him. Some of them knew about his girlfriend in college, but that’s all they knew. They both were not exactly pining in the space of that four plus years after that last call is my feeling. He didn’t sit around playing the guitar, singing songs and making videos. He took up the cut short corporate career and became incredibly successful. So did she in her way, getting an MBA and then joining a good firm. In that short time she must’ve made an impression. Didn’t he also start off with RDX? She tried dating, he must have too, still is for all we know. But they both have always resided in each others mind and heart, never leaving. And once they are again in front of each other, those feelings again rush to the forefront. Was that video made after that first meeting in kolkata?

        Liked by 11 people

        1. OMG you read my mind!
          P echo of thoughts literally to each and ever word!! I don’t need to write anything about Khushi, you said it all and how exceptionally explained!! Muah! Muah! Muah!!

          I wouldn’t have been able express all these thoughts! It’s a relief to see it from you!!

          Okay, you’ll beat me if I ask you about when kolkatta? I feel it dates after A&M recruitment and seeing her at the campus…..

          Liked by 10 people

        2. Wonderfully analyzed Priya! Bang on for both not exactly pining for each other ! Their relationship never went far enough for either of them to pine still it always was there in the background like a wound that never healed properly.

          Liked by 11 people

        3. It is always a pleasure Priya…. to relive the River days and moments when you coherently pull together moments from various updates and present us a beautiful view of their relationship! It was a treat in deed to read your comment.

          As you said, he must have tried moving on too…. while he succeeded at the career front, guess it was not the case on finding his love. Agree with you on his concern, and how he might have opened up to NK after being worried about her staying alone, especially after he knew that he’d spent the weekends with NK and she will be stuck in her hotel room. And also knowing that NK will invite her when he knows about her.

          On whether the video was taken after Kolkata…. could be either ways….sigh!

          I was initially upset when the 2nd interlude told that he’d not been thinking of her much after IE-V until that song about River and Ocean which triggered her memory for him. That was the time when we all wanted him to have been pining for her. But now, we see it… after the River camp, he is trapped to this girl forever. The songs. … they are just words straight from his heart!

          Liked by 9 people

        4. Priya,

          As usual, tumne pate ki baat bol di.

          In hindsight, everyone can be wiser. But in that situation, she took the decision based on information available to her at that time and suitable to her way of dealing with things.

          I guess he did the same thing. We all do it. Does that mean we regret/reconsider/doubt/confirm it later? Yes, we do.

          Because the available information and our temperament changes with passing years. Sometimes, ee get a chance to revisit and rectify what we started thinking as wrong. Sometimes we do not get this chance and we treat the loss caused by that decision as a sunk cost.

          Sometimes even after years, we are not sure.

          Liked by 10 people

          1. Sunk cost, there speaks a finance person😄 I was one in my previous avatar, switched fields, some might call it mid life crisis. One of the best decisions of my life, have to say
            Both of us, the miniscule minority have been saying the same things like a broken record for a while now!

            Liked by 7 people

            1. I sometimes wonder why we are in minority. And then I realize we both believe that people do not get fairy tales or happily ever after as it is portrayed in popular media.

              Even if AV and Khushi are together, will that make everything perfect for them or each of them without efforts?

              If two people want to be with each other, it has to be free will and acceptance of other as a human being with failings.

              People are bound to make mistakes, break expectations, regret, get angry. AV and Khushi should be together, not because they are and will be perfect but in spite of imperfections.

              Liked by 8 people

              1. I have wondered the same. Are we as women, harder on others of our sex? Why is it hard to give her the benefit of doubt, when we can overlook what he did, write it off as silly and a mistake of youth. Maybe its my age😄
                Absolutely, they should be together because they want it inspite of imperfections and be equal in many ways.

                Liked by 9 people

        5. Beautiful comment Priya. Many of us have thought of the same while reading the story but you said it :)
          I can imagine how happy Meera must be ,to see that people read it between the lines, whatever she wants to convey.

          Liked by 6 people

  2. Wow.. khushi is really enjoying the trip .. I love it.. alone time is a real bore. I just hope she goes to meet her old buddies.. it ll make a more memorable trip.

    I ll definitely give ur recommended stories a try. U r all so talented. :) waiting for the next!

    I love pani da .. and barun loves that song too haha. So apt for arnav khushi

    Liked by 7 people

    1. “AV usually comes down and stays with *us*. ”

      Interesting! It is a typical manner in which couples refer to themselves (sometimes without even realizing it).

      The question is do we (and Khushi) know at least one person in the remaining part of us.

      Liked by 10 people

        1. Priya,

          I was thinking of Nishant sir after reading last update. :-D

          And here he arrives. I am curious about how much he knows about AV Khushi history.

          I agree that AV is a private person but in that respect Khushi is worse. Did he ever had any confidante? If yes, who?

          Liked by 10 people

          1. That YT link was a total bouncer. I mean I thought it must be from their college days and not recent. But what do you know. I don’t feel he (NK) knows. A confidante, if any might be his jeeja

            Liked by 9 people

                1. Or maybe campus interview when he was invisible to her or 3/4 years ago somewhere after the third call. This has to be after talking to her…seeing her…otherwise he will be the river devdas 😕

                  Liked by 7 people

              1. It is one of my all time favorite Gulzar songs.

                I love the film too but Khushboo is slightly more favorite. Maybe, because it is based on a story written by Sharat babu.

                Liked by 4 people

          1. The song lived in my blood at some point of time in my life Madhu, so many memories and so many smiles with this one …for so many reasons –
            – Simple lyrics yet so Powerful, dunno what to do with the man who wrote them! His imagination, art … uff!!
            – felt like it was recorded when Bhupinder was not aware of it. He has sung it like one would sing in a jam session, totally relaxed enjoying and having a good time with his friends over a couple of drinks 🙂 Im still in awe of how beautifully he has sung it, it’s so difficult to sing a number like this!
            – trust RD to make a stunning song out of prose, magician that he was!!

            The songs from Kinara are stunning! Love all of them 🙂
            The one Meeru has used is so beautiful, and so apt for the update! 🙂

            Liked by 6 people

            1. Sohniye,

              The man who wrote those words!!!! I do not mind if I do not get all AVs of this world but this man in white hold my heart in his hand for decades now.

              Liked by 5 people

    1. Was it just me or did anyone else feel their heart break just a little when reading about the yearning in Arnav’s eyes? Wasn’t that the reason why Khushi’s eyes filled with tears? Years of guilt…indeed.
      The heart knows…but the mind chooses to disbelieve.
      AV doesn’t miss anything that includes the tiniest change on her face. Did her eyes widen behind her glasses at the luxury of the other hotel? Did she show her admiration in a smile? What ever it was, he did not miss it. Isn’t that an indication of the attention he pays to everything that is related to her? Isn’t that an evidence of his fixation on her? Or did she put that too down to a lucky co-incidence?
      Nishant sir is back and how!! I was smiling when I read Nishant. I loved this guy meera…not that it means that I want him complicating matters, but I hope he is happily married/hooked and is wanting the same for his friends.
      Maybe NK could provide the push that Khushi.
      Can we please, please have her go to his house next weekend. She cannot change her mind now!! And he has invited her already…just how many times does she want someone to invite her?
      It was a pleasant surprise to read about AV and Nishant continuing their boy-band :).
      Oh, how I wish I could attend one of their sessions :D
      I do hope there is not another girl in the band NK and AV have going though..unless it is NK’s significant other. I do think that another girl in this juncture would push Khushi further away. She already thinks she has no rights to be jealous.
      I had no doubts that AV still sang. After all music is entrenched in him. I did think the video was one from an earlier Arohan though.
      AV- what else can I say about the man that hasn’t already been said? When did he realize that Khushi was the one for him? Last I remember, he did say he wasn’t ‘in love’ with her yet but thought he would get there very soon…then from that when did she become the person he yearned for silently? Did he even try to move on? Date someone else when he realized that he kept looking for those beautiful eyes obstructed by those glasses even when the person in front of him had perfectly made eyes unobstructed by anything? And why was he still waiting? Is it because he is waiting for her to get shackled before he gives up? From where does he get the hope, the strength, the courage to wait especially without knowing if the wait will ever be fruitful? I really want to know.
      He carefully gives the keys to her without the slightest touch..sigh..
      The song you have chosen meera..one of my favorites. But, I am just back from the SPB 50 concert and when he sang this song, I could only picture Barun in his AV avtar :D :D. So here’s the song…AV ke naam..

      Loosely translated the first few lines of the song means

      o lightning, why did you come?
      why this hurt in my eyes…
      from my sky why did you suddenly vanish.
      You came only for some time
      But you burnt me within that time

      It is a beautiful composition by AR Rahman, sung by SPB…to be listened via headphones with the sound slightly on the higher side. Sorry I am unable to translate more…I suck at translations. Anyone else can have a go.
      This song is one of ARR’s best IMHO.

      Liked by 12 people

      1. AV is observant…maybe even more when it concerns her. The guy always always spoke less..but not with her .
        Another girl in the band..why not..NK wife/gf? Nk bolne laga hain:) gone the college shyness.

        Liked by 8 people

      2. Is it because he is waiting for her to get shackled before he gives up? From where does he get the hope, the strength, the courage to wait especially without knowing if the wait will ever be fruitful? – The hope is she being here with him in Detroit, he wants it that’s is why the wait and this time he is not going to listen to her 😈

        Liked by 8 people

      3. You should definitely translate the next line!
        “Minnale.. yen vaanam unnei theduthe…” That for me, when listening, pulls at my heartstrings ALL THE TIME!
        Translation: “O lightening! My sky yearns for you!”

        Thanks for sharing this song.. I totally agree, one of ARR’s best!

        Liked by 3 people

  3. Love that Nishant sir is back in the picture and Khushi seems interested! Can’t wait for the mini reunion and May 1st couldn’t come sooner

    Liked by 7 people

  4. Hi,the update was like a splash of cool water for a parched traveler.have been waiting for the update eagerly. What a wonderful style writing. Thanks for the river.

    Liked by 5 people

    1. Normally I don’t take this long to comment. AD is..I don’t need to say I guess.. I read the update IMMEDIATELY though.
      Pani da!!! One of my favourites. A song that I dedicated to my husband when he was abroad for quite sometime. Specially the “Tere uthe marda..” part. And it suits these two aptly! How you weave the story with songs like these Meera… not just mention the songs, but weave a complete emotional scene with it! I was feeling melancholic over there.. How much more can this man express himself? And he wouldn’t have expected her to know about this song.. How did Arjun come across this anyway?
      Nishant sir is back in the story! :) What did he mean by ‘us’? Is he married? Living with a girlfriend? Roommate? If it’s the third, then will jealousy play a part with AV, as NK is not committed, and Khushi would be totally easy going with him?

      Liked by 3 people

  5. This is the power of your writing – for a second, I really thought of looking up AV and Nishant’s video on YouTube!! And crazy that I am, I am still going to search to see the results … lol..
    Even though I am happy about the progress AV and Khushi are making and will be making in next update, I realize it’s another chapter down to finish line and that makes me panic! Are you going to have River available on this blog even after its completion? If not, turning it into an e-book will be a great idea (wink – wink) just saying 😁

    Liked by 10 people

  6. Was waiting for your update and what an update it was. Worth the wait. So, NK is back. While I read your story I can picturize all the moments in my head. “Pani da rang” matched the mood of the update. Through Khushi you have so aptly portrayed the indecisions and insecurities we deal with in everyday life, yet creating your own fairytale. Brilliant. Thank you. Will be eagerly waiting for the next part.

    Liked by 6 people

  7. Omg Nk is back!! And he lives in Detroit?? Who is this us?? Is he married or lives with roommates?? But if he invited khushi may be he is married??
    Oh they still sing together and make videos … wow … that is so awesome!!
    Aare waah Kaveri ji had her first solo drive in US and also her first retail therapy 😜
    I so excited for their meeting… feels as if I’m going to meet them 😜
    Why did Arnav not share where he is going and ask her to join him?? Wapas confuse kiya … I thought he would try to spend every free minute with khushi!! But he did ask her abt breakfast in the morning… hmm May be he only wants to spend time with her alone 😁
    Was it only me or did anyone else think this was a short update!! I was like bas that’s it chapter over really… did I skip a few paras?
    Eagerly waiting for the next update 😍😍

    Liked by 15 people

  8. Beautiful part…loved it Till today morning I was like yesterday is 22nd and today is 23rd (IST) y haven’t u updated but i was wrong abt date. I was sooo happy that it’s 22nd today and update I wait super eagerly for ur updts

    >

    Liked by 5 people

  9. This one was one happy chapter I suppose.. and the video.. kaaasshhh we could get it for real😇😇.. Nishant sir.. I actually missed him.. hey hey.. will the three make a video together. Wowwww.. I hope that happens😁(wishful thinking 😉)..
    P.S: needless to say.. Meera diiii.. you are an amazing amazing writer and my inspiration… Thank you😇😇

    Liked by 8 people

  10. Something about AV sir really makes me choke up with all these EMOTIONS and I just want to cry or for Khushi to do so…You know, just.. let it gooo…Ahem, anyway I..watched FAN right before I read the update and as I was reading, the movie’s last scene was fresh in my mind..In which the fan is gazing at the star from the crowd..And I couldn’t help but connect it to the feeling that I think Khushi, me and everyone else has around AV , like he’s a star and unattainable. we can wave at him from the down below and see him climb the ladder to success , he might catch a glimpse or two of us in that crowd and give a moment of thought but the ultimate reality is that his place is up there where he can shine with his full potential..And where.he can see not just us but thousands or more others like us ….Beside him anybody else who isn’t like him will always be a shadow…. Hidden by his brightness…. We know he’s just a normal guy with similar circumstances but the sum of all his small good points is much much larger than the parts of it….A person can be his number one fan but they will still always be only one fan… Even if he wants us to go towards him, he’s just too far up.for anyone to reach ..So how could Khushi go forward with him … Their whole relationship has been so unbalanced from the get go….He had an unfair amount of power over her since all this while.. so I won’t blame her wanting to take at least some of that back and thats ok , however I don’t like how she decided something and is crying about the misfortune now like it was not her own doing… I’m on her side totally about why she did what she did initially but not after that phone call..See it’s ok if she is upset and doesn’t want to meet…But she wanted to see him from what I can tell and still didn’t and that is something that had me a little mad….No I’m not asking to forgive him right away or even afterwards but damnit girl go and meet him if that is what you want , don’t let these insecurities and doubts stop you… Confront him, shout at him, let all the steam out instead of letting it stew inside and eat you up for years.. Don’t sit there passively, do something about your issues …That’s all I ask….

    Liked by 14 people

  11. When I saw the title,I was wondering about “full circle”…But not in my dream I would have thought that NK wwill also make a come back after ten years…. When Arjun metioned about NKs interest in khushi,I actually missed the man thinking that his role is over …. Then you gave the you tube video… maybe I didn’t get that correctly eventhough I read the update four or five times… What I thought is the video was taken after college, but didn’t think that it’s this new….So actually I wasn’t eexpecting him at all… But the phone ring n us no, ring a bell…I’m glad that I knew it’s nk even before he made the classical music training statement… This is getting more and more interesting… Who would have thought This man’s entry…I hope nks presence will bring some changes… Does he know about AV n hers past?
    After the behene de update, most of the days I sleep listening to the same… Now I guess I could try panida today…(but behene de
    will remain on the top ..It was really something…The evening still playing in my head every now and then)
    When you simply say AV singing , the song get a whole different touch to it… How much I wish that youtube video is actually a real one….!
    I don’t know how would I last till may first…..!

    Liked by 12 people

    1. Fantastic as always Meera and early🤗☺
      At least this week I won’t be distracted at work knowing I have an update waiting to be read and savored.

      Full circle ( almost) it is in many ways….
      Khushi is interacting with AV daily, and now Nishant Sir is back and working at the same company.

      That was unexpected, as was the video ( although it was fun to speculate )

      Will Nishant help ease the lingering awkwardness dissipate? His invitation implies a shared home – with his wife?
      Did she take the video? ( another round of speculation. ..)
      And how did she know to focus on his eyes…..AV is not someone who would have shared his innermost feelings with anyone, barring TD.

      Here is an opportunity for khushi to finally get to know Arnav – not AV Sir, not AV – just Arnav.Who he is now years from from the River camp.
      Is it time for her to lose the hero worship and get to falling in love.

      I so want her to take the first step….Arnav’s wait and his current control deserves that.
      Makes me wonder about that 4th phone call – is that the reason for Arnav maintaining a professionally friendly persona with Khushi? A word given to her or maybe to himself – to let her decide if she wants him in her life.

      tu apne dil ki jawaan dhadkanon ko gin ke bataa
      meri tarah teraa dil bekaraar hai ki naheen
      dabaa dabaa saa sahee dil mein pyaar hai ki naheen

      teri umeed pe thukaraa rahaa hoon duniya ko
      tujhe bhee apne pe ye aitabaar hain ki naheen.

      dabaa dabaa saa sahee dil mein pyaar hai ki naheen
      Jhuki Jhuki see nazar…

      Liked by 14 people

      1. Did she take the video? ( another round of speculation. ..)
        And how did she know to focus on his eyes…..AV is not someone who would have shared his innermost feelings with anyone, barring TD.

        -Mon – How did you even think of who shot the video!!!! I could’nt get past his eyes :)

        Liked by 10 people

      2. Loved your take, Monica. Certainly an opportunity for Khushi to know Arnav better, minus the awkwardness and the stardom, to realize he is just a boy, standing in front of a girl, asking her to love him…..to reverse quote Notting Hill, that never seems too far from Khushi’s thoughts or the fandom’s! And yes, the third phone call, was that crucial one that pushed him away and pulled the rose tinted glasses off him…no wonder he is like a cat on a hot tin roof with her these days….bitten more than once, bechaara. My favourite from the Jagjit Singh gems…thank you, it is so perfect here. 🙏🏼😘

        Liked by 10 people

    1. Khushi, what is it that ails you sweetheart? 😓😓 Did you not mourn your heartbreak at all since the camp?

      Why does it feel like she clamped shut all these years, like she just now scratched the surface of a magnanimous decision, just opened the floodgates? Why the iron grip over her heart? Is it a fear of being perceived as weak? Letting it out doesn’t make one weak sweetie, just light. This is such a huge reflection of her upbringing isn’t it? Her parents prepared her for a successful career, watered and nurtured her hopes and dreams, enabled her to take valiant steps, steps that were never presented to them. They coached her to go above and beyond to capture her aspirations, and theirs. But sadly they didn’t prep her heart for emotional journeys, or courage to pursue her it’s call. They were lucky to find in one another, eccentricities, like mindedness, friendship, and love….however muted it may seem. The very prevalent act of discouraging anything but education is relatable to a great extent and I’m certain it resonates roaringly among many of us. Romance is never allowed any space, even in jest. In short, nothing that takes away precious moments that could be spent reviewing something for a millionth time. We can argue that Trip didn’t get baited. She is the exact opposite. That just doubly makes Khushi the yes mom, yes dad child. She over compensates for her sister’s audacious personality. Their acts of shunning the world and limiting their involvement with people have been passed along and Khushi’s social skills are almost negligible, if any. There’s nothing wrong with this. For some people solitude is the only companionable companion and it makes them perfectly happy. But Khushi fell in love with a man of the world, she stumbled into something her parents probably never did. Can one stay aloof in love? Of course her foray in to it didn’t end pleasantly for her. But even if it did, love comes with needs, would Khushi even be able to deliver?There’s so much propriety in her world. Would she be fair and giving in love? Poor poor Khushi, she is a victim of her parents’ ineptitude at making emotional connections.

      “The reason birds can fly and we can’t is simply because they have perfect faith, for to have faith is to have wings.”
      ― J.M. Barrie, The Little White Bird

      Her lack of interest in living life is sad….or is it only around Arnav that she’s skittish? But this is not entirely surprising. With Khushi there’s not too many surprises. She follows the script of her life closely. Does she not sing anymore? What about other hobbies? Does she still know the words to every song there is? Does she keep up with Bollywood? Was everything buried along with Arnav five years ago? This chapter made me realize how little we know of her. What she did these 5 years is as shrouded in mystery as Arnav. For someone who didn’t forge lasting relationships, she sure is a very lucky young lady that all these people from her past come knocking on her doors again, seek to bridge the gaps. She was loved, radiated a warmth that people liked, was yearned even. How is it that she’s the only one that’s uninformed of her worth?? When will she discover faith?

      And I presume Arnav waits in the darkness…..without hope, without knowing what he’s waiting for, but with a lot of faith that the wait will end.

      “My heart, the bird of the wilderness,
      has found its sky in your eyes.
      They are the cradle of the morning,
      they are the kingdom of the stars.
      My songs are lost in their depths.
      Let me but soar in that sky,
      in its lonely immensity.
      Let me but cleave its clouds
      and spread wings in its sunshine.” – Rabindranath Tagore

      Apologies again Meera, repeat offender here. I hate it that you deliver as promised every single time, and I don’t manage my time well enough to comment on time. Love this chapter. You make me fall in love with Khushi a little deeper every time and I totally understand her hesitations. While I can probably lecture a room full of strangers, I would rather die than go to a coffee shop or a movie alone 😶😶. I understand why she needs Arjun..which in a way is good, because it means she’s not totally a loner. There is still something that can be salvaged 😜. So great job on that solo trip to Walmart. I’ve never been to Detroit. I’ve always thought of it as a monster garage, gray and dull. I must say you don’t motivate me to book tickets anytime soon 😂🤣😂🤣. I hope the weeks that went by wasn’t too hard on you, and the one that’s coming up is easy breezy. Thank you Meera and have a great week everyone 😘😘.

      Liked by 11 people

      1. NEVER apologise for being late or for not being here! Life takes precedence over fiction always. And thank you for such lovely words each time. My life is all tumbled and tossed at the moment and at such a time the River and its people are my constants. For that I can never thank all of you enough!

        Liked by 9 people

      2. There is so much in this comment.. not sure where to start first. You say how little we know of her. I agree. Do I now have one more person who would like a Khushi’s interlude :) Between the camp and now.. that is five years..besides school and work…what else does she do? You are right.. does she still sing? She has been in Bangalore for 5 years.. any other friend beside Arjun ( first 3 years he was in Lucknow) and Tripti ( always another city)? She is a loner? It would help me understand her better.. if we know more about her.

        What we do know she is very comfortable in work life. After the camp debacle she gave an excellent interview for the television crew and I am sure as a consultant her work is great including her presentations. So the issue is like you said in her social interactions. Role model- parents who did not interact much socially. She lack social skills or she just prefers her own company? I am not sure. She did finally approach Arnav at the camp, initiate a kiss too ( she did?) Was that an outlier … she was out of her comfort zone?

        Her lack of interest in life… it appears so right? ( Except work.. though it was a pleasure to read about her buying the blue shirt) Or is that we do not have much information about her.

        From the little we know of her of till now.. these words of yours ring true for me “love comes with needs, would Khushi even be able to deliver?There’s so much propriety in her world. Would she be fair and giving in love?” (And this is not about Arnav and his misdeeds 10 years ago or 5 years ago and her hurt. I would ask the same thing if she married someone else). Will their love make everything right?
        PS. Now I think it has to be Arnav who will have to understand her and break the barriers ( whatever they are).

        Liked by 6 people

        1. Just a thought
          When she started at I.E.-V, she must’ve been 17/18. Then finding herself the cynosure of attention due to her unique position as the lone girl, she was not expecting love, she was feeling bad about not been on her favorite campus, but fall she did. Then the whole aarohan fiasco happens, she is said to have not performed up to her usual standards (academically) in the beginning, then pours all her energy into getting over and getting back on track academically. At that age probably the combined aspects of the situation made her withdraw into herself, develop a shell. There’s a line about tripti knowing better than to rouse a wounded tigress/lioness post aarohan. She is naturally on the quieter side (she had replied that it helps now when AV questioned about her reticence). I wonder whether what happened made her fall into a pattern which becomes deeply entrenched over time. A sort of defensive tactic.
          Sorry if I’m making no sense😄

          Liked by 6 people

          1. Priya I agree heartbreak- irrespective of age and personality hurts. So yes post Aarohan her behavior made sense.
            Fast forward few years in the camp though she approaches him.. talks about losing a few pounds…initiates a few other things too (not in a shell)… after Arjun’s revelations she made a decision. The decision was not made in haste. She stuck to it. Not reticent.
            Five years later that is a long time.. most of us change. Not in school ( end of cocoon existence and out of parents home), alone, she has been working in Bangalore for last three years. Heartbreak, betrayal played a big role in her life. Like Sapna asked above has she not pondered over it? Maybe she has not, too much heart ache so she does not think about it. So what are her early morning pondering.. when she does not talk to anybody? I thought she reflected on things and maybe herself ( if not AV then maybe about her parents….why she lets important people go…something about why she is the way she is…). .
            Her behavior now is like she is back to IE-V days… from “I cannot do this alone” to skirting the parking lot to avoid him. Revert back to your 17 year old self when she is around him? Her half smile to him…it is almost like she wants him to be his old friendly self with her ! He needs to show vulnerability ( both songs affected her) for her to react?He skipped telling her about NK ( every acquaintance counts in a unknown country), take you out for breakfast if you want to….no dissection on her part? Or I need to be patient as I am weaving an impression with little information :)

            Liked by 3 people

        2. My two cents on Khushi :)

          Khushi will be able to deliver love at least to her family and her friends. Her family and Arjun would have noticed if she was lacking in that department or living a depressed life… she continued living her normal life as one would. Her personality has always been like that few connections and few friends. She is not a loner, I think.

          Even during IE- V days, she was not ready to sing, Arjun forced her to sing. She sang her first song in front of AV and then she sang with AV. She started enjoying singing with him. Singing with him brought her joy and much more along with it. It was not a hobby for her, the way it is for AV.

          Liked by 5 people

          1. Agree she has always been quiet, not exuberant like tripti or raagini. In her case it was not just once but twice bitten! Whenever she in a sense stepped out of her comfort zone, made a move if I may say so, things happened. In a way she tried to protect herself from pain, and going back to the prologue that line about her basic instincts about people…

            Liked by 4 people

          2. Well said Lavz…I don’t think she’s depressed either…she’s not the most happiest camper, but not depressed is a good guess. Although I know depressed people mask their depressive tendencies better than anyone else. I just think some life skills are missing…like interactions with people other than family…which usually come from watching parents and their interactions with others. But in her case her parents (esp dad) seem a bit preoccupied or absent minded, or not interested. Or cooking….it’s a life skill and must be taught to all kids that understand safety. We host a couple of exchange students every yr (12-15 yr old) and most of the ones I’ve had are from Europe. It always amazes me how responsibly they cook. I always ask at what age they began to cook and it almost always is 7 or 8. Most Indian kids I know are not allowed near the stove well in to their teens. And we very proudly tell our kids ‘ all we want from you is to study hard and succeed’ 😏😏.
            As far as hobbies, Arnav has a more public persona, his hobby is for everyone to see. I kinda think singing is her hobby too, or memorizing lyrics is…but she pursues it privately. This chapter just made me wonder if she still does that or anything else besides devouring books.
            Talking about absent minded, yours truly forgot to pick up kiddo yesterday. And I’m sure I haven’t heard the last of it. She let my entire extended family in the universe know of it 😒😒

            Liked by 5 people

            1. I know there us a very intense discussion going on… but going to pitch in with a stupid tidbit… yours truly went to grocery store to buy salt, came home after an hour with $100 bill but no salt. The look on hubby and in laws and daughter! 😢

              Liked by 5 people

            2. Yeah makes sense about her hobby :)

              Events, conversations have to happen for her to see things. Just Introspection will not help Khushi. Meeting different people, exposure, not just colleagues but old acquaintances will definitely do her good. Setting, situations, and conversations will definitely bring out the side of her which will be surprising for herself and that will start the process of transformation. She is already taking baby steps, I see it. Khushi’s phase of defining moments is here I think :)
              (I dogged a lot before I started realizing :D )

              Makes sense Sapna about life skills. It all depends on the environment and culture one grows up with. I did not cook until I had no option but to learn cooking 😆. And human interactions as less as possible, it took me a long time to realize that people don’t bite and I can talk to them 😄.

              About news traveling to the extended family, get ready for weird looks and how can you do it questions! 😄😄
              I understand the absentmindedness. I really do now. There was a time when I used to argue about it and now I do the same thing, sometimes the plate get loaded I guess :)

              About exchange students have heard lot of stories, cooking is a good habit but I know hosts who got into trouble because of their alcohol drinking age (Europe) 😄

              Liked by 4 people

          3. Absolutely (not a expert but as a lay person) she is not depressed. No one else other than Arjun is her friend in IE-V. If she did not participate in Aarohan she would have never interacted with NK or for that matter AV. It helped her to meet people who she liked. Arjun her only friend…which she would let go. Many of us do as we move.. but me make new friend(s).. she does not. Is work all she does…her interest in her health is also Raagini. High bar for friendship maybe relationship too?

            Liked by 3 people

            1. All things that happen usually to us are because of situations, we don’t go looking out for things. Arjun IE-V , Aarohan everything happened because she was in a setting. Friends happen, Ragini happened just like that to Khushi.
              The exercising point was pronounced more because of Shyam but that doesn’t mean she doesn’t think about her health. She has always thought about it and figured out the reason for it.
              Becoming friends always is a process. She never initiated it I guess but when something clicked she became friends. After college or university, it is hard to make friends at least that I can surely vouch for. It gets hard.

              Maybe Shradha if it is high bar then it is a high bar, it doesn’t have to be like that I understand :)

              Liked by 3 people

              1. I get what you’re saying lavz. She’s not a gregarious person, but that doesn’t mean she’s a complete recluse too. Actually in many ways they are similar, which we may miss. He’s mystery man, he doesn’t talk so much. Even Aditi had pointed that out, how similar in dispostion they are, going against her theory of opposites coming together.

                “So I was saying….I always assumed that couples work best only when they are opposites. My parents, Aman and I, Munna and Saira…I mean….” She paused and bit her tongue. “Sorry…”
                Khushi shook her head. “It’s fine. You don’t have to apologize.”
                “See?” Aditi piped up. “This is what I mean. This is almost exactly what Arnav would have said.” She said excitedly even as Khushi frowned. “He really would have. And any conversation with Arnav would have gone one exactly like this. With me talking and he indulging me every once in five sentences.” She raised her hands up in the air in mock-exasperation. “You are so…alike in temperament. And that…I have never seen that. It’s like…Edward Ferrars and Elinor Dashwood…They never made sense to me. Now Marianne and Colonel Brandon – that was…it was…expected – Also because the man is literally mooning over Marianne for half the story.””

                She’s not the kind who will become the life of the party where ever she goes, like Arjun. Would most likely try and fade into the background, I get that, I’m like that. I find it difficult to just start conversations with people. Now with him we’ve always seen him situations where he was seen as a star, the only time we have seen him otherwise was at the river. But unlike her he’s probably more comfortable in his skin.

                “Her – the fat girl who had always wondered what being loved by someone other than family would be like, the new teen who had been laughed at when her crush had been discovered in school. The sounds of laughter as the object of her affection had scoffed at the possibility of her crushing on him years ago echoed in her head. It was not a memory she had allowed back into her consciousness even though she knew it was what drove her and her reactions.”

                I find that heartbreaking. Sometimes things, words linger, they come to you when you least expect it, that’s just the way it is, part of being human I guess. Signing out, see you all on monday😄

                Liked by 3 people

                1. P – such accuracy!! Kudos to Meera for writing the story with consistency keeping characters intact and yet defining the changes with every new update. And kudos to you for extracting it out to explain something when it becomes little blurry.

                  Aditi explaining Khushi about AV and it makes so much sense now. He speaks less but does when it is required. AV being around her now, the link between them, what binds them is reflection of Ti-Di’s explanation…
                  Khushi’s memory is painful, agree about words coming back……but new experiences will aid :)

                  Liked by 2 people

                  1. She tries to adopt things that she likes in others, like how she ponders that she wouldn’t have even thought of trying any of the activity at the river if not required to, if not for arjun. How his enthusiasm has rubbed off on her. Likewise when she’s around AV, seeing him interact with people professionaly and otherwise (actually even during IE-V days during pratice there is a bit when she notices how he handles people when they come to him with questions) will hopefully help her.

                    Liked by 3 people

  12. Hey Meera… AV really meant it na… The way he sang Pani da rang with that something in his eyes 😍😄 … I think Nishant is probably married… coz when he extended the invitation to Kaveri he’d said that AV comes to stay with ‘us’… If he’s not married and still in line… AV sir would be the one to feel jealous instead of khushi… Waiting for the next one….

    Namrata

    PS: I know I’m posting a comment after a very long time…But it’s just that I’ve been too caught up…And it takes me a lot of time to read..breathe in each word of my favourite story… Reread…And then say something….Plus the way everyone on the river writes their comments…like a story in themselves…mine seem really inadequate… Please post the next update as soon as possible… Please

    Liked by 6 people

  13. Wow I should give pat to my back myself for being not soooo late!!!
    The song & the expression I was imagining on AV was true, yes’s yes’s somewhere I could feel by reading it …… it was for K.Khushi 😘😘
    Kab tak ignore ya avoid karegi yeh ladki😓😓,mera toh matha chakra raha hai iss ladki ki avoiding act se!!
    Khushi is still having feelings for him & so is AV for all these year’s.
    At least Khushi is guilty thinking somewhere she is wrong.
    WOAH🤓🤓 Nishant-Sir was defiantly surprise package here☺☺
    Well this next weekend trip would be fun,like really fun filled!!!

    Liked by 6 people

  14. Aha, Meera! Aap ka post aaya tho bahaar aayi :-) Life has indeed come full circle.. or at least about to next weekend at NK’s :-)

    NK? He says AV stays with “us”. So I am not worried, he’s mostly taken. Perhaps NK is the catalyst we all were looking for.

    Yeh AV-KKG ka ‘mouna-raagam’ and ‘mouna-geetam’ kitne din chalega? She’s still stealing glances (is that all?) at this man with the glasses… 10 years after a similarly staged Aarohan performance. Like everyone else, I was actually expecting the video to have been the post-Aarohan tit-bits from IE. So this one was a googly indeed! ;-) wow!!
    And every time you mention Aarohan, I am reminded of my Carnatic music teacher stressing so much on getting the Arohanam and Avarohanam right during our class. “Teek se gaao, nahi tho poora kirthana (song) kaise gaayega?”, this amazing musician would say, in her broken Hindi (she was a Tam, I am not and we lived in a cosmopolitan city where Hindi was the primary language of communication). Feeling so nostalgic today…

    Meera, you described the tender post-dinner moments on a Friday night so well, that here I am.. tempted to dedicate this lovely song picturized on Shammi Kapoor and Sharmila Tagore at their sensual best in the city of romance:

    Raat ke humsafar, thak ke ghar ko chale
    Jhoomti aa rahi, hai subah pyaar ki
    Dekh kar samne roop ki roshni
    Phir luti ja rahi, hai subah pyaar ki

    Kya kya vaade huye, kis ne khayi kasam
    Is nayi raah par, humne rakhe kadam
    Chup saka pyaar kab hum chupaye to kya
    Chup saka pyaar kab hum chupaye to kya
    Sab samaj pa rahi hain, subah pyaar ki

    Liked by 9 people

  15. NIshant Kumar Pathak…. this was a surprise !!
    As everyone calls AV, a mystery man, I think if there would have been any other college mate other than Kaveri, he surely would have mentioned it to Nishant. He is deliberately keeping Khushi out of the loop, out out of his life, even in simple office talks.

    Khushi should accept Nishant sir’s offer. It will bring a whole lot of positive change in her. Because with Arnav, she can’t even have a normal conversation. May be with NK, and his family, she will be more open. They may talk about college (other than AV ofcourse ), life and have fun. The more she will talk, more she will be at ease..

    How we wish that video to be on youtube.. Sigh !!
    Waiting for May 1st.

    Liked by 6 people

  16. Some resistance, this!

    Of course, our ocean is a much better conductor of electricity than this river, especially as it refuses to emerge through a dam(n).

    I need a superconductor, yo. Atleast, some charged ions (read as “namak ishq ka” ;-))

    Don’t kick me out of this blog.
    Running away now.

    P.S. Like Behne De wasn’t enough!!!

    Liked by 7 people

  17. I also want to see that video 😉😉
    Very beautiful song….apt to show how Arnav feels . Still waiting for khushi …
    I like how khushi feels the little pang of jealousy and also the way she was desperate to see the video for the first time and re- run it again…..muted feelings are surfacing again😉😉
    A pleasant surprise…Nishant sir also stays in Detroit. Khushi should really accept the invitation and visit them along with Arnav .

    Liked by 5 people

  18. Awesome update as usual M!!! What a surprise update on a Saturday not on a Monday where I have to pretend a little now I just need to ignore hubby which he is happy as that will give him more sports time lol!!!
    Coming to the update aww poor Khushi nobody should be in her place, seeing AV day in and out must be so tough. Ahh throw Nishanth to the mix this is going to be interesting, didn’t Arnav tell him as he knew Nishanth had feelings for her. For some reason I feel like he must be married with little babies running around lol!!! Cannot wait for Arshi visit to their place.
    I am already on board with Begin Agian and love Raj and Anya Meena is doing such a good job with the story, totally love it. Everyone should give the story a try!! I will try your other recommendation now that I am being ignored ;-)

    Liked by 5 people

    1. Milke ke hum na mile tumse na jaane kyu, meelon ke hai faasle tumse na jaane kyu
      Anjaane hai silsile tumse na jaane kyu, sapne hain palkon tale tumse na jaane kyu
      Kaise batayein kyu tujhko chaahein yaara bata na paayein…
      baatein dilo ki dekho jo baaki aankhein tujhe samjhayein
      Tu jaane na – Tu jaane na

      Nigahoon mein dekho meri jo hai bus gaya woh hai milta tumse hubahu
      Jaane teri aankhein thi ya baatein thi vajah
      Hue tum jo dil ki aarzo
      Tum paas hoke bhi tum aas hoke ke. ehsas hoke bhi apne nahi
      Aise hi humko gile tumse na jaane kyu, meelon ke hai faasle tumse na jaane kyu
      Tu jaane na …

      Liked by 9 people

    2. “Paani Da “… What a beautiful song Meera … the words just kill you … you couldn’t have chosen a better song for Arnav’s state of mind …
      ”Kothe utte baihke, ankhiyaan milaunde
      Na jaana humein tu kabhi chhod
      Tere utte marda, pyaar tenu karda
      Milega tujhe na koi aur …
      Waiting for the next weekend to come … hope Nishant Sir is able to get through to Kaveri to get through this protective shield that she has created around herself …

      Thank you Meera …

      Liked by 11 people

  19. A nice chapter. I am beginning to pull my hair out at how slow Khushi is. I wish she would do something in order to move ahead in life, if not for anything, but for herself.

    Liked by 6 people

  20. Oh wow! Khushi is being slowly and surely pulled back into the magic of her first foray into romance. AV and Nishanth, the two magic makers together and how can poor Khushi resist it? Arjun pushing on one side, AV pulling on the other, Khushi has no choice but to succumb to her heart. Time for her to shed her cloak of self-doubt and indecisiveness.
    Another brilliant chapter Meera. I just love how you’ve brought in Nishanth Sir. I’m hope you’re going to make him the catalyst who will give Khushi and AV that much needed push.

    Liked by 4 people

  21. Closure…..I wonder what that thing is! Without it, you can get stuck at one point of your life without even realizing it…I am hopeful for Khushi….she badly needs one to move on in life….with or without Arnav…..I also want to meet this future version of Nishant-Sir… it was a beautiful update….I loved it <3

    Liked by 5 people

  22. I dunno if it’s just me or not, I found Khushi in an almost tranquil and serene atmosphere in this chapter. Even though the music video and the encounters with Arnav would have stirred her heart a tiny weeny bit, which is always bound to happen, it feels like they are taking the required baby steps. And I am happy if they continue doing so. Though Khushi is trying hard to take steps back by avoiding unnecessary encounters with Arnav, she still notices those tiny flickers of emotion playing in Arnav’s eyes.

    Everyone deserves a second chance. In their case, it would be totally worth it! Hope she realises it sooner.

    But then, it takes time to forget.

    Sometimes it is easier to forgive and forget than ‘Just Remember’ because memories are a powerful thing.

    Let everyone find their true happiness which they are bound to.

    Thank you for a lovely update! Looking forward to the next one as well. :)

    PS: If you don’t mind, can I please get access to your story ‘A word’s worth’ ?

    Liked by 6 people

  23. Dear Meera,
    It’s been longtime I read your stories. Sometimes, personal life takes you to hell and stories like yours brings solace and peace to my life. Yours stories are not one of those typical m&b’s. I am absolutely in love with your stories the way you combine music and lyrics. I just finished rereading your stories in India forums that are available. And came across this River story. I finished reading it in one go. (I remember doing that last when HP Deathly Hallows part two was released! ) And can’t wait for this story to unfold. I am a South Indian and learnt Hindi watching movies and when living north India for sometime. But your song collection has made me learn the language more in depth to understand the language and have started thoroughly enjoying Gulzar’s Saab lyrics. My favourite chapter is Raavan song chapter Behenede…usirepogudhe in Tamil. Thanks for writing such wonderful stories. I just can’t explain how your stories brought back the music in my life when I was struggling to hold on to some semblance of normalcy in otherwise tumultuous personal life. can I get your email id? Really would like to talk and get back to my ipkknd world of authors.
    I don’t see many in the India forums except Rockbarbie.
    Once again thanks and keep writing these wonderful stories.
    Take care
    Niki

    Liked by 6 people

  24. Have not been commenting for a long long time, not because I was it looking forward to reading the story every time it was posted; due to the bloody Asli Duniya! Meera your story keeps me from sinking more into melancholy.
    Thank you for keeping it up!

    Liked by 4 people

  25. Of course she will be the one to take the initiative this time, Nivi. She has to. I mean ….what the….after walking away so many times, give the man his respect! Seduction and insanity…most definitely. And, AV’s yearning and Nishant Sir’s playing Cupid….ah, such digestible images! Let’s see where it all leads up.

    Liked by 6 people

  26. I read the update in loop and listening to Paani da in loop..but did not comment as I am grieving in sorrow for pain and yearning in AV’s eyes..so went back bad read the update the only day they were happy..and noticed his bday was March 17th..and found out Kushi reached Detroit in late Feb..one week in project and next weekend is AV’s bday and they will celebrate it in NK’s place..NK will force Kushi to sing..Meera,you are always giving us pleasant surprises like NK reappearance..for once make my silly prediction come true..pleaseeee…That would be too filmy for your writing style, I feel you will reveal that last phone call on that day instead..am happy whatever it is..am happy if Kushi takes him on a bday date too ..this is tooooo much K serial wala filmy ..has haaa.
    I have officially gone crazy at mid night early morning..lol

    Liked by 10 people

        1. It will give her an excuse to wish him..otherwise she will just doodle his name in a hidden paper on his bday.😀 maybe the weekend will thaw their relation..so she can wish him if bday is on a weekday. Geez so much speculation..meera must be laughing 😀

          Liked by 5 people

            1. Lol…Divz..what you doing :) first she had to deal with the bed and breakfast speculation….first time….breakfast menu for him..now this :) but yes…bday will be on a weekday..the two need to be alone…and she will wish him and more . I sound like sohni now :)

              Liked by 4 people

              1. 😁 We can make suggestions na! The rest is up to our pyaari authorji ke woh sunne ya nazarandaaz karein! 😉😄

                As for sounding like Sohniye – yeh sab sangath ka asar hain! 😉😂

                Liked by 2 people

  27. And yes, I have a feeling NK is happily married and looks like his wife is very supportive of his music ad friends staying overnight..she might make friends even with Kushi..who knows, she might push Kushi towards Arnav..

    Liked by 5 people

  28. Meera,

    Amazing chapter….the video was certainly a red herring from the last episode, right? It was of AV and Nishant Sir from the present. Glad they retained a hold over the things that truly mattered to them. So necessary to make the time to do that in life. NK will certainly be the one that gives their ostensibly doomed love a new lease of life. As someone who knows them both from back then, revelations are certainly in store that will change the tide….if anything will. Khushi’s inertia and mode of insulating herself in a protective shield will only break when some disturbance forces it and makes her move. This could be it. NK might do what Arjun couldn’t yet. Paani da is an eternal favourite and sure provided the scope to let our hero yearn for his beloved in peace…..in the most filmy style, she catches the yearning too, reflected in his eyes and that makes her squirm almost in guilt. Good she still has the conscience to do so! So yes, the tectonic plates in the lives of our River and Ocean are certainly shifting again. Cannot wait!

    Hugs,

    Anu

    Liked by 13 people

  29. And yes, in keeping with tradition, Kishmish this one is specifically for you as you always stop to ask what would be the River song dedication for each chapter….Ashiq Tera Tera…from Happy Bhagwan Jaayegi…..do not know how to post the link….but will include some of those lovely lyrics:

    Hosh baaton ka akhsar nahi tha,
    Dil hamara toh shaayar nahi tha,
    Tu ne likh dee ye takdeer varna
    Ishq waala mukaddar nahi tha…..

    Kite jaa tu kiye jaa
    Ab kuch aur sittam

    Such a magnificent composition! 🙏🏼🌈🌺

    Liked by 9 people

  30. Meera, after waiting ten days for their weekend , it is not fair to send A V out of sight.You are such a tease
    dear, how soon is the ‘SOON’ to get
    mysterious A V interlude?Loved
    loved and loved the update.

    Liked by 3 people

  31. Are we gonna have the same setup and crowd live IV when there is a confession ? I feel so.. most of IV is still in touch or around .. Nishant sir was a pleasant surprise intro.. anyways the thick air between arnav and khushi needs a release.. awesime chapter

    Liked by 2 people

  32. Can’t believe how long I was waiting for this update and now I have to begin another long wait!! Meera – a couple of friends and I are yours and River’s ardent fans. We were discussing last week how wonderful it would be if you could make this story into the next IPK with Barun and Sanaya 😊.. here’s hoping and wishing and keeping fingers crossed.. May 1st please come sooooon 😊 hope AD is slightly less busy for you next week…

    Liked by 2 people

  33. Something flickering in is eyes. Could that be a hug he wanted to crush her? The smile he didn’t return- He would have expected her to say ” Oh I would like to come along” – and Khushi being Khushi still prefers to live with her own insecurities and doubts rather than to go out, reach out to people, come what may.
    And when everyone was expecting the original Aarohan , this is a googly from you Meera. And the song, wow! soul stirring. No surprise, hard core ice is melting.
    Is he a saint? what made him wait for her even after so long? He still remains a mystery to his own pal after so many years. What was that shuffle and phone voice of Nishanth getting dimmed, Is Arnav making a sign to Nishanth not to talk ?
    Amazing, amazing, amazing update Meera. Hope Khushi will not change her idea of visiting Nishanth next week end.

    Liked by 4 people

  34. I would have taken another page to write about River song along with my comment, so a decided to put it as it’s own 😃

    The song is a masterpiece! The lyrics are eternal. It’s thought provoking and yet not weighed down with heavy words. It grabbed my attention the day I heard the song for the first time. Young age probably didn’t help me to comprehend the song fully, but it remained very dear to me through out my growing up years. Gulzar saab’s narration at the beginning stole the thunder of the song, only he could render it the way he did. His lines reach the heart and depth of his voice makes it soulful for me. No offense to the singers in the song but the first four lines by Gulzar Saab killed it for me.

    The river song enhanced the update like no other. This is the best river song for me, the timing, the placement, the impact! Perfect choice of song for the update.

    Liked by 7 people

  35. Oh my previous comment got posted incomplete :(

    Dear, I’m unable to understand what Khushi is up to!!!
    She confuses me

    Is she guilty of the way she handled Arnav 5 years ago??
    Is she running away from facing the consequences??

    She wants a closure or she wants Arnav to move on So that she will automatically decide her fate??

    Will wait for next update, eagerly!!!

    Liked by 3 people

  36. Beautiful update as usual,looks like their z going to be reunion of music gang of arohan minus aman ofcourse.What flickered in AV’s eyes or is it khushi’s imagination.

    Liked by 2 people

  37. I am Late!
    After reading this part should I say they are taking baby steps to know each other well. My sixth sense is telling me ‘Nishant sir’ will give much awaited push to our kkg. Waiting for their reunion. Happy to read your work after long time.

    Liked by 1 person

  38. Such are the ways of River and Oceans lol. She is taking her time meandering thru life. Sometimes she she moves with direction thru life, other times life and obstacles give her direction. Ocean just silently watches and waits.

    AV, the ultimate professional is being so careful to keep just the right balance in this boss and subordinate relationship so for him to tell Nishant she is here is normal and to some degree brilliant because now he has introduced her around and he is not the sole responsible person for her well being.

    The music video got to me…reminded me of the ‘good old days’ of the first crush and college heydays. I still will not be happy till Kaveri cries some serious tears for what I consider to be her lack of maturity, judgement and good old hissy fit.

    Meera – can we get his perspective….please introduce us to the man he is today!!😊

    Liked by 3 people

Say something?